614-968-5010
104 Granville Street
Columbus, OH 43230
Open Tuesday-Saturday 10am-6pm
Minimum 48-hour notice to order a whole cake.
Call to place your order!
Whole Cakes
$49
AMAZING CHOCOLATE CAKE
Rich chocolate cake with chocolate icing.
$49
$49
AMY'S WEDDING CAKE
Dense wedding-style cake layered with raspberry jam.
$49
$49
CARROT CAKE
3 moist layers embellished with a tart cream cheese frosting.
$49
$49
HUMMINGBIRD CAKE
A bananna-pineapple spice cake.
$49
$39
TIRAMISU
Delicate lady fingers pastry soaked in espresso, and coffee liqueur with a touch of chocolate and sweet cream filling.
$39
$49
LEMON BLUEBERRY
3 layers of cake with hints of lemon and blueberries throughout.
$49
$49
CASSATA CAKE
Sponge cake layered with ricotta cheese and chocolate chips. Topped with strawberries.
$49
$49
COOKIES AND CREAM CAKE
3 layers of dark chocolate cake filled and frosted with Oreo buttercream and topped with chocolate ganache.
$49
$49
PEANUT BUTTER CHOCOLATE CAKE
3 layers of dark chocolate cake with peanut butter icing. Layered and topped with chopped and whole peanut butter cups.
$49
$49
Chocolate Gingerbread Cake
$49
$49
Ultimate Cookie Cake
$49
$49
Pumpkin Cake
$49
$49
Banana Chocolate Chip Cake
$49
$49
Drunken Chocolate Cake
$49
$49
Nutella Chocolate Cake
$49
$49
Kahlua Coffee Cake
$49
$49
Coconut Cake
$49
Whole Cheesecakes
$49
ALMOND AMARETTO CHEESECAKE
Rich amaretto cheesecake topped with toasted almonds.
$49
$49
CHOCOLATE CHIP CHEESECAKE
Classic chocolate chip cheesecake.
$49
$49
CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER CHEESECAKE
Chocolate peanut butter cheesecakes with peanut butter cups.
$49
$49
DREAMY LEMON CHEESECAKE
Delectable lemon cheesecake.
$49
$45
PLAIN CHEESECAKE
Plain cheesecake without toppings.
$45
$49
BAILEYS CHOCOLATE CHEESECAKE
Chocolate cheesecake made with Baileys Irish cream.
$49
$49
LEMON BLUEBERRY CHEESECAKE
Delightful combination of lemon and fresh blueberries.
$49
$49
CHOCOLATE ALMOND COCONUT CHEESECAKE
Very rich combination of chocolate, almonds, and coconut.
$49
$49
KEY LIME CHEESECAKE
Everything you love about key lime pie in a cheesecake.
$49
$49
TRIPLE CHOCOLATE CHEESECAKE
For true chocolate lovers.
$49
Available in store
$2.25
BAR COOKIES
Rainbow cookies, peanut butter brownie, chocolate brownie
$2.25
$14
/
lb
BULK COOKIES
Assortment of traditional Italian cookies
$14
/
lb
$1.25
BISCOTTI
Chocolate or Almond
$1.25
$5
CANNOLI
Assorted varieties
$5
$8
CAKE BY THE SLICE
Assorted varieties
$8
$8
CHEESECAKE BY THE SLICE
Assorted varieties
$8
$1.50
COOKIES
Sarah's Italian Cookie, Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter
$1.50
$3
CUPCAKES
Assorted varieties
$3
$7
TIRAMISU
Single piece
$7